The daily fantasy sports (DFS) landscape has been through many twists and turns, with major players like FanDuel and DraftKings at the forefront. However, a significant legal battle has recently captured the attention of business owners and industry insiders alike. On May 23, 2024, the New York Appeals Court ruled in favor of the founders of FanDuel, who alleged that the company was significantly undervalued during its 2018 acquisition by Paddy Power Betfair, now known as Flutter Entertainment.

FanDuel, a trailblazer in the DFS industry, was founded in Scotland in 2007 as Hubdub Ltd. by Nigel Eccles, Lesley Eccles, and Tom Griffiths. Initially focused on bets centered around real-world events, the company pivoted to daily fantasy sports by 2009, making a significant splash in the US market. By 2015, FanDuel found itself in a fierce marketing battle with DraftKings, its primary competitor. The intense rivalry led to an attempted $3.3 billion merger in 2016, which was ultimately blocked by US competition authorities.

Following the collapse of the merger, FanDuel’s board restructured the company’s shares into two categories: “Preferred Shares” and “New Ordinary Shares.” Two significant shareholders, Shamrock Capital Advisors and KKR, held a combined 36% of the Preferred Shares, granting them the power to compel other shareholders to accept a merger or acquisition offer.

In 2018, FanDuel’s board began to explore financing options and enlisted Moelis & Company, a financial advisory firm, to assist in the process. During this period, the US Supreme Court heard Murphy v. NCAA, a landmark case that led to the repeal of the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA). This decision opened the floodgates for legalized sports betting in the United States, placing FanDuel in a prime position to capitalize on the burgeoning market.

Subsequently, negotiations for a merger with Irish betting conglomerate Paddy Power Betfair commenced. However, the deal became contentious when the founders and over 100 shareholders, representing 10% of FanDuel’s share capital, filed a lawsuit challenging the terms of the merger. They argued that the Preferred Shareholders exclusively benefitted from the deal due to an alleged undervaluation of FanDuel’s assets, resulting in a claimed loss of $120 million.

The lawsuit began in Scotland, but significant developments occurred in the New York legal system. Initially, a five-judge panel in the New York Appellate Court dismissed the case in 2022, stating that the founders had not made a valid claim under Scottish law. However, the recent ruling by the New York Appeals Court reversed this decision, allowing the case to proceed.

The court’s statement read, “The Appellate Division correctly concluded that Scots law applies to plaintiffs’ claims and appropriately took judicial notice of its content in resolving defendants’ motion to dismiss. We conclude, however, that plaintiffs have sufficiently pleaded causes of action for breach of fiduciary duty under Scots law. Accordingly, we reverse the Appellate Division order.”

This ruling is a significant victory for the plaintiffs, underscoring the complexities involved in cross-jurisdictional legal battles and the application of foreign legal principles in US courts.The FanDuel case highlights several critical lessons for business owners and industry stakeholders:

Ensuring a fair and accurate valuation during mergers and acquisitions is paramount. Undervaluation can lead to significant financial losses and legal challenges, as evidenced by the FanDuel case. Business owners must engage reputable financial advisors and conduct thorough due diligence to avoid similar pitfalls.

Cross-jurisdictional legal battles can be complex and challenging. Understanding the legal implications of operating in multiple jurisdictions and preparing for potential legal disputes is essential. Businesses should seek legal counsel with expertise in international law to navigate these complexities effectively.

The repeal of PASPA had a transformative impact on the sports betting industry, illustrating the profound effect regulatory changes can have on business operations and valuations. Staying informed about regulatory developments and adapting business strategies accordingly is crucial for maintaining a competitive edge.

The FanDuel case underscores the importance of fiduciary duties and ethical practices in corporate governance. Ensuring that all shareholders are treated fairly and equitably during mergers and acquisitions is vital for maintaining trust and avoiding legal disputes.

The triumph of FanDuel’s founders in the New York Appeals Court marks a significant milestone in a protracted legal battle over the undervaluation of assets during the company’s 2018 acquisition by Paddy Power Betfair. As the case proceeds, it will continue to serve as a valuable reference for business owners, highlighting the importance of fair valuation, legal preparedness, and ethical corporate governance.

The final outcome of this case could have far-reaching implications for future mergers and acquisitions in the rapidly evolving online gaming and sports betting industry. Business owners must take heed of the lessons learned from this case to navigate the complexities of corporate transactions successfully. Stay tuned for further updates as we continue to monitor this landmark case and its impact on the industry.

Leave a Reply

Interested in our Solutions?

    Interested in our Domains?